| Karceski S, Morrell M, and Carpenter D. The expert consensus guideline series: treatment of epilepsy. Epilepsy & Behavior 2001;2:A1-A50.
For second monotherapy:
Experts recommended LAMICTAL for conversion from carbamazepine or phenytoin in adults with partial seizures
The experts
51 leading physicians in epilepsy treatment, selected on the basis of recent publications and representing a geographic cross-section of the United States (45 responded)
The objective
| • |
To identify an overall approach to treatment, experts were asked to rank the order in which they would recommend certain therapies |
| • |
Using a modified 9-point scale (developed by the Rand Corporation), experts were asked to rate specific treatment choices |
The survey
| • |
Designed to address key decision points in the management of epilepsy and seizures |
| • |
Contained 21 questions about 808 treatment options covering four main clinical scenarios:
- idiopathic generalized epilepsy
- partial seizures (symptomatic localization-related epilepsy)
- symptomatic generalized epilepsy
- status epilepticus
|
Data analysis
Consensus was established for three ranges of appropriateness (1-3, 4-6, 8-9) according to a chi-square test of the distribution of scores:
| • |
First line: confidence interval (CI) >6.5 |
| • |
Second line: CI 3.5 to 6.49 |
| • |
Third line: CI <3.5 |
The question
Partial seizures (symptomatic localization-related epilepsy): second monotherapy: Suppose that the first therapy is tried to clinical tolerance and produces either no reduction of seizures or only a limited response. Assume you would next choose a second monotherapy trial and that the antiepileptic medication shown at the top of each section is your first choice. Please rate the appropriateness of each of the following therapies as a second monotherapy in this situation.
The results
|